Washington — As House Speaker Kevin McCarthy looks to follow through on his pledge to keep Democratic Rep. Ilhan Omar from serving on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, it’s unclear whether he will be successful given opposition from some of his fellow GOP members.
McCarthy has long threatened to hold a vote to deny Omar a seat on the panel if the GOP won the House majority because of past comments she has made about Israel, which rankled Republicans and Democrats alike. But GOP leaders also see the move as retaliation against Democrats who voted to strip two Republicans of their committee assignments over incendiary social media posts when they controlled the House.
Republicans now enjoy a narrow majority, and McCarthy can only afford four GOP defections in order to successfully garner the votes needed to keep Omar from holding committee seats.
But already, two Republican lawmakers, Reps. Nancy Mace of South Carolina and Victoria Spartz of Indiana, have indicated they will oppose McCarthy’s effort against Omar.
“Two wrongs don’t make a right,” Spartz said in a statement. “Speaker Pelosi took unprecedented actions last Congress to remove Reps. [Marjorie Taylor] Greene and [Paul] Gosar from their committees without proper due process. Speaker McCarthy is taking unprecedented actions this Congress to deny some committee assignments to the minority without proper due process again.”
Spratz referenced votes in the Democratic-controlled House, which earned support from some Republicans, to strip Greene and Gosar of their committee assignments. The two lawmakers have each received spots on two House panels in the new Congress.
Referencing the earlier votes targeting Greene and Gosar, Spartz said she will oppose the “charade” and pushed McCarthy to “stop ‘bread and circuses’ in Congress and start governing for a change.”
A third Republican, Rep. David Joyce of Ohio, told the Washington Post last week that committee assignments should be addressed “within the confines of each party” and said the votes against Greene and Gosar “creates this retaliatory issue for our conference.”
Further complicating McCarthy’s path forward is the absence of GOP Rep. Greg Steube of Florida, who said he will be home in Sarasota for “several weeks” recovering from a 25-foot fall from a ladder.
While proxy voting allowed absent House members to enlist another lawmaker to cast votes for them in the last Congress, McCarthy did away with voting-by-proxy once he gained the gavel.
It’s unclear when House Republican leaders might move to vote on removing Omar from committees. McCarthy told reporters Tuesday that he is “not at all” concerned about securing the necessary votes, and House Majority Leader Steve Scalise said Wednesday that Republicans have “no intention” of having Omar serve on the Foreign Affairs Committee, and California Reps. Adam Schiff and Eric Swalwell sit on the Intelligence Committee.
“If people have shown a propensity to either espouse anti-American, antisemitic views, do things that have put themselves in a compromised position including lying about classified information, it raises serious questions,” Scalise said.
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries tapped Schiff and Swalwell for the Intelligence Committee, but the Republican leader plans to block their appointments, which he can do unilaterally since it’s a select committee.
Omar told reporters on Tuesday that she has “good standing” on the Foreign Affairs panel. In addition to Republicans who have publicly expressed opposition to her removal from the committee, many others have spoken with her privately and said they believe the move is “unjust,” she said.
“They are trying to do whatever it is that they can within their conference to make sure there is no vote to remove me from the Foreign Affairs Committee,” Omar said.
Omar drew distinctions between former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s decision to hold the vote to kick Greene and Gosar off of their committees in the last Congress and what McCarthy is seeking to do now.
“They threatened the lives of their colleagues. They posed danger to folks that they could serve on committees with, to the actual institution they were sworn to protect,” she said. “Unless McCarthy can say how myself, Adam Schiff and Eric Swalwell are a danger to the institution, our colleagues, then he’s not following the example that was set by Speaker Pelosi.”
Ellis Kim and Rebecca Kaplan contributed to this report
