The University of Idaho plans to begin demolition today of the off-campus rental home where four undergrad students were killed in a home invasion stabbing last year.
The house at 1122 King Road is a grim reminder of the slayings, which is now boarded up, fenced in and guarded 24 hours a day.
Some critics of the decision, including several family members of the victims, want the house to remain standing until the suspected killer, Bryan Kohberger, goes to trial. However, keeping the house standing could prove to be a “logistics nightmare” that does not impact the jury in the long run, one expert said.
Other high-profile murder cases have involved jury visits to the scene of the crime with mixed results. O.J. Simpson was acquitted of murder charges in his early 1990s trial for the deaths of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman. Jurors convicted Alex Murdaugh in the shooting deaths of his wife and son after visiting the family’s Moselle estate earlier this year, where prosecutors said the disgraced South Carolina lawyer gunned them down near the dog kennel.
BRYAN KOHBERGER TRIAL: MOTHER OF IDAHO MURDER VICTIM FIGHTS TO KEEP KING ROAD HOUSE INTACT
The Simpson case was unique, said David Gelman, a Philadelphia-area defense attorney who has been following the Idaho case, because it was so highly publicized and because the defense was able to pepper the house with family photos in an effort to make the defendant look better to jurors.
He said in a shooting case, if there were a dispute over distances or angles, a firsthand look could help jurors.
The house where four University of Idaho students were fatally stabbed is cordoned off in Moscow, Idaho, on Friday, Dec. 15, 2023. (Derek Shook for Fox News Digital)
Otherwise, he told Fox News Digital, it is a logistical “nightmare.” Jurors, alternates, the judge, the lawyers, law enforcement and other courtroom staff need to be transported and kept secure, fed, and accommodated for bathroom breaks. He does not think it is always useful for jurors’ understanding of the case.
IDAHO STUDENT MURDERS: DEMOLISHING KING ROAD HOME BEFORE TRIAL A ‘TERRIBLE IDEA,’ INVESTIGATOR SAYS
A bus carried jurors, officials and members of law enforcement to Nicole Brown Simpson’s condo in Brentwood during O.J. Simpson’s murder trial on Feb. 12, 1995. Judge Lance Ito, second from right; defense counsel Carl Douglas, second from left; and Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Deputy Guy Magnera are among those who visited the scene. (AP Photo/Eric Draper)
“Nobody wants to do it,” he said. “To say it’s rare – it’s a unicorn.”
After serving as both a prosecutor and a defense attorney, he said he has only tried one case where jurors were taken to the scene.
He successfully prosecuted an arson suspect accused of lighting a house on fire with victims inside. It was the defense who insisted on going to the scene.
You’ve got to get 12 jurors, plus your alternates, get them onto a bus, get them there on time, make sure nobody is touching anything or talking to them. You’ve got to feed them. You’ve got bathroom breaks. And then you’ve got your staff, the prosecution, the defense, the court staff, the judge, everybody has to be there, along with law enforcement. The logistics alone is a nightmare.
“I don’t think it did anything,” she said. “I think it was theatrics. I think it was the defense attorneys were grasping for straws.”
Jurors, during their deliberations, did not ask any questions about the scene, he said.
“Usually when you go to trial it’s at least a year after the allegation occurred,” he said. “So by that time the scene is done. You’re not gonna have yellow tape everywhere, you’re not gonna have bloodstains, and you’re not gonna see anything.”
WATCH: Tour of Alex Murdaugh’s former estate Moselle where double murder occurred
Other experts have told Fox News Digital that the university’s bid to demolish the building is a decision that prioritizes the school’s aim to “move on” above the potential impact a firsthand look at the crime scene could have on jurors in the case against Kohberger.
“Being able to visit the crime scene in certain cases is extremely important,” said Edwina Elcox, a Boise-based defense attorney whose clients have included Idaho’s “cult mom” killer Lori Vallow. “Video and pictures can help, but may not accurately depict the scene in the way an in-person visit can do. The house should be preserved until the trial concludes or Kohberger pleads guilty.”
The victims of the Nov. 13, 2022 University of Idaho massacre, from left to right, Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Madison Mogen. (Instagram @xanakernodle / @maddiemogen / @kayleegoncalves)
Police arrested Kohberger on Dec. 30, weeks after the murders, after he took a cross-country road trip with his dad back to his family home in Pennsylvania. At the time of the slayings, he was studying for a Ph.D. in criminology at Washington State University, about a 10-mile drive from the King Road house.
He allegedly killed the four students across two floors in the three-story building, sparing two other housemates, one of whom told police she saw a masked man while peeking out her bedroom door.
Bryan Christopher Kohberger arrives at Monroe County Courthouse in Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, on Jan. 3, 2023. (The Image Direct for Fox News Digital)
GO HERE FOR MORE TRUE CRIME FROM FOX NEWS DIGITAL
Kaylee Goncalves and Madison Mogen, both 21, were discovered in an upstairs bedroom. Under Mogen’s body, police found a Ka-Bar knife sheath they say tested positive for Kohberger’s DNA.
On the middle floor, responding officers found the bodies of Ethan Chapin and Xana Kernodle, both 20.
Defense attorney Anne Taylor joins investigators on a visit to the King Road crime scene on Jan. 3, 2023. The house was the scene of a quadruple homicide in November 2022, the victims all being students at the University of Idaho. Taylor will be defending Bryan Kohberger, who is charged with the murder. (Derek Shook for Fox News Digital)
The landlord donated the property to the University of Idaho earlier this year, and officials announced plans to raze it and build a memorial garden, which, according to Chapin’s family, is being designed by UI architecture students.
Attorney Shanon Gray released a statement on Wednesday from the Goncalves and Kernodle families, who said they had “reached out to the Latah County Prosecutors Office and the University of Idaho to stop this madness” and preserve the house until Kohberger’s trial “for basic evidentiary purposes.”
“When the victims can’t speak you have to speak for them when you feel someone is hurting the case,” they said.
“We all along have just wanted the King Rd. Home to not be demolished until after the trial and for us to have a trial date so that we can look forward to justice being served,” they added, pushing for a trial date to be set. “Is that really too much to ask?”
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Kohberger’s trial had initially been scheduled for October, but he waived his right to speedy proceedings and has focused on challenging the indictment and DNA evidence instead.
Goncalves’ family, in a Facebook post, lamented the decision to tear down the building and said Dec. 28 would be “a very sad day.”
